Neither Terry Pratchett nor Neil Gaiman ever quite gelled for me

Oh man, I'm glad to know I'm not the only one! I have found a couple instances of each of them that I enjoyed, but it was definitely a "slog through six books trying to get it, give up, eventually find that one short story or one book that clicked."

That said, my friend who's storing all my possessions is SO INTO Good Omens right now. In my case, we eventually read it due to fandom work, and man did Fandom Telephone give us a very distorted picture of what the book was about!